Who Will the Phillies Fifth Starter be in 2020?

When the baseball season returns (if at all), there is still one more glaring question facing Joe Girardi’s squad. Who will be the fifth starter in the 2020 rotation?

To start, the competitors for the spot are Vince Velasquez, Nick Pivetta, and Ranger Suarez. Velasquez has never been very good for the Phillies, posting a 4.12 ERA in 2016, 5.13 in 2017, 4.85 in 2018, and 4.91 in 2019. He has had some instances where he has been very good, which is usually when he is throwing his fastball quite a bit. When he was in the bullpen for some time during the 2019 season, he did pitch marginally better, but not great. I feel that Velasquez’s future with the Phils is most likely as a late-inning bullpen arm. He would probably do better if someone told him to go pitch one inning and throw as hard as he can. Personally I’ve seen quite enough of Velasquez over the past four seasons, and I would be fine if the Phils decided to move on.

Competitor two is Nick Pivetta. His stats over his three seasons in Philadelphia have been very similar to Velasquez. In 2017, he posted an ERA of 6.02, in 2018, 4.77, and last season, 5.38. He also had a WAR of -0.5. Yes, not 0.5, -0.5. The Phillies decided with Pivetta just like Velasquez last season, to move him to the bullpen where he did pitch quite well for about two months. Pivetta, just like Velasquez, throws hard, so I also think Pivetta’s future with the team is in the bullpen. I’d be very happy to have him in the bullpen this season.

The last player, the underdog, is Ranger Suarez. In 2018, Suarez didn’t pitch too well in his four games, posting an ERA of 5.40. Last season, he pitched in the bullpen for the majority of the season posting a respectable ERA of 3.14 in 48.2 innings of work. Though he only started two games last season, Suarez is my favorite for the rotation spot. He pitched the best out of the three competitors for the spot last season, and I think he has the brightest future of the three players.

Ranger Suarez would be my pick for the fifth rotation spot in 2020. In 2019 he posted a 3.14 ERA in 48.2 IP.

Suarez is my favorite for the spot; what’s yours? Visit my Instagram @philliesnews_ and vote in the comments of my recent post on Velasquez, Pivetta, and Suarez.

1 comment

  1. Pivetta and Velasquez have shown, in essence, what they are – and it’s not so good. The dearth of pitching available to the Phillies in the last couple of seasons (due to injury, lack of farm system development, whatever) is the reason they continue to be given chances. The truth is, they are high-level minor leaguers. That being said, I agree with the author’s assertation that Ranger Saurez has the highest upside. The Phillies are not projected to be division leaders this season. Therefore, give Saurez the opportunity to grow and possibly, shine. Pivetta and Velasquez have already used up their opportunities.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: